Project Description
Key information
Project in the Spotlight: T20008
Market: Advanced Metals
Written M2i Program Manager: Viktoria Savran
This research was carried out under project number T20008 in the framework of the Research Program of the Materials innovation institute (M2i) (www.m2i.nl) supported by Holland High Tech | TKI HSTM via the PPS allowance scheme for public-private partnerships. The Dutch railway asset owner ProRail is acknowledged for its contribution to this research.
When a Small Rail Defect Becomes a Bigger Problem: Faster Prediction of Squat Crack Growth
Railway tracks experience millions of wheel passages during their service life. Over time, the repeated contact between wheel and rail can cause rolling contact fatigue and lead to defects known as squats. What may initially appear as a relatively small surface defect can develop into a complex crack below the rail surface. Understanding whether such a crack will continue to grow is important for deciding when intervention is needed and for avoiding unnecessary rail replacement.
PhD researcher Sjoerd Hengeveld from Eindhoven University of Technology under supervision of Davide Leonetti, Bert Snijder and Johan Maljaars have developed a new modelling approach that could make this assessment considerably more efficient. In his project Sjoerd combines fracture mechanics and finite-element modelling to develop a simplified representation of squat geometry and a computationally efficient method for estimating the crack driving forces.
For ProRail, the practical question is how information about a visible squat can be translated into a better assessment of the crack developing beneath the surface. Such a mechanics-based assessment could help distinguish between defects that can continue to be monitored and those that require intervention.
Why squats are difficult to predict
Squats are not simple cracks. They develop under repeated wheel loading and have a complex three-dimensional geometry. Their crack growth behaviour is also influenced by factors such as wheel position, thermal and residual stresses, vehicle-track dynamic interaction, and the combination between successive wheel loads. Assessing all relevant scenarios using detailed finite-element models can therefore become computationally demanding.
Sjoerd approached this problem by first developing an idealised geometry that captures the main characteristics of a squat, based on real squat geometries. Rather than treating the defect as a planar crack, the model distinguishes two stages. The first stage is a shallow, relatively wide crack close to the rail surface. The second extends deeper into the rail and is represented as an elliptical crack. This simplified geometry retains the features needed for fracture-mechanics calculations while making systematic analysis possible.
Figure Squat fatigue crack growth in rail: Left, squat after fracture of the rail Right, developed two-stage squat schematisation.
From detailed simulations to rapid calculations
The next step was to determine how wheel loads affect the crack. Sjoerd used three-dimensional finite-element models in which a moving wheel is represented through a Hertzian contact-stress distribution. Thermal stresses and different lateral positions of the wheel were investigated, reflecting the fact that the wheel-rail contact area may change due to presence of a squat.
Figure 1 Finite element (FE) model used for evolution of crack driving forces: Top, schematisation of FE model; Bottom, example of FE mesh and (block-wise) mesh refinement.
Running a detailed finite-element analysis for every combination of crack geometry, wheel loading, thermal stress and other operating conditions would, however, require considerable computational effort. Sjoerd therefore developed a superposition framework. Instead of recalculating the complete problem every time, the framework combines solutions for basic loading cases, particularly normal force and bending moment, to rapidly estimate the resulting crack driving forces.
An important feature is that the method distinguishes between situations in which different parts of the squat are open or closed. This allows the interaction between the shallow and deeper stages of the squat to be represented without having to reproduce the complete finite-element problem for every new loading scenario. A comparison with squat fatigue crack growth in operational conditions showed the potential of the framework
Why this matters for railway maintenance
The practical value of the approach lies in the computational efficiency. Detailed finite-element models are essential for understanding the mechanics of squat in rails under different loading conditions. However, the loading of a rail is never represented by one perfectly defined wheel passage. Wheel position, axle loads, temperature and residual stresses vary, while the geometry of the crack itself changes as it grows. A computationally efficient model makes it possible to explore these variations and, ultimately, to incorporate fracture-mechanics calculations into probabilistic crack-growth and remaining-life assessments.
This remaining-life assessment can subsequently be used as input for maintenance decision making.
From research model to railway practice
The project brings together fracture-mechanics research at Eindhoven University of Technology and the perspective of ProRail as the Dutch railway asset owner. This connection is important because the developed model ultimately needs to represent the loading conditions and defect behaviour that matter in railway operations. ProRail contributes railway data, practical cases and technical expertise, helping to connect the modelling work to the conditions and practical challenges encountered in railway operation. TNO can assist in making the theoretical framework applicable to the railway network.
Sjoerd Hengeveld: “The main challenge was finding the right balance between capturing the complexity of squat cracks and the corresponding loading and keeping the model efficient. I hope this work can ultimately help us predict more accurately how squats grow and when maintenance is needed. After my PhD, I will continue working on rail-related research at TNO, so for me this is certainly not the end of the topic. ”
Bart Schotsman (ProRail): “For infrastructure managers like ProRail, such approaches contribute to a more informed distinction between defects that can continue to be monitored and those that require intervention. Rather than relying on a framework of ultrasonic testing and fixed repair schemes, future assessment methods could increasingly consider the mechanical conditions that determine whether the underlying crack is likely to propagate.”
Henk Slot (TNO): “This project demonstrates the excellent collaboration between universities—focusing on more fundamental, long-term research questions—and applied research. It has yielded a rather complex fracture mechanics model that applied research institutes, such as TNO, can run on behalf of ProRail.”
Project related publications
- Hengeveld, S. T., Leonetti, D., Snijder, H. H., & Maljaars, J. (2026). Crack path under non-proportional fatigue loading — Evaluating tests with existing crack growth direction criteria. Theoretical and Applied Fracture Mechanics, 141, 105069. doi:10.1016/j.tafmec.2025.105069
- Hengeveld, S. T., Leonetti, D., Snijder, H. H., & Maljaars, J. (2026, June). Transferability of fracture condition from compact tension shear tests to squats in rails. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 340, 112169. doi:10.1016/j.engfracmech.2026.112169
- Hengeveld, S. T., Leonetti, D., Snijder, H. H., & Maljaars, J. (n.d.). Rail squat idealization for rapid stress intensity factor solutions. Engineering Fracture Mechanics. (Submitted)
- Hengeveld, S. T., Leonetti, D., Snijder, H. H., & Maljaars, J. (n.d.). Residual life prediction of squats in rails. (In preparation)




